Concierge Orthopedics | Expert Second Opinion

(860) 735-3744
Book Online
Refer a Friend

Not Bad Enough for Surgery, but Still in Pain? Here Are Your Options

Posted on: October 20th, 2026 by Connor Ziegler

If you’ve been told to “come back when it’s worse,” you are not alone.

Your knee or shoulder hurts. It’s changing how you move, how you sleep and what you’re willing to try on the weekend. You’ve seen someone about it. Maybe you’ve had an X-ray, an MRI or an injection. And the answer you walked out with was some version of: you’re not bad enough for surgery yet, so let’s wait.

I talk about this with a lot of my patients. The pain is real now. Waiting a few years for it to get worse is not much of a plan.

Why so many patients hear “come back when it’s worse”

Most orthopedic care is organized around one big decision about you: do you need an operation or not?

If the answer is clearly yes, there’s a well-worn path. If the answer is clearly no, there’s a different one. But you may not fit neatly into either group.

I put it this way:

“You know, the industrialized orthopedic model really creates an avenue for either non-surgical or surgical, and really doesn’t do a lot for people in between.”

I call what I do holistic orthopedics: I look at the whole person, including the joint, the diagnosis, your overall health and what you want to get back to.

Are you in the “middle 50%”?

When I explain this to my patients, I use a simple framing that may help you see where you fit.

“The way I frame it with a lot of my patients is that there’s 25% of people that are very clearly indicated for surgery, probably 25% of people that are not indicated for surgery, and that could be from a multitude of issues, their station in life, their overall health profile, their baseline function.”

Those percentages come from what I see in my own practice.

If you’re in the middle group, I think you’ve been underserved.

“And this middle 50%, which I feel is grossly underserved, which, you know, come back and see me in a few years when it’s bad enough to do surgery. But that patient is having pain now and no one is helping them at this time in their life.”

Two questions matter here: do you need surgery, and what can you do now?

What you can do now, even if you’re not a surgical candidate

The first step is getting the diagnosis right. That means a careful exam, a look at your imaging and a real conversation about your goals.

From there, I build a plan around you and what you want to get back to.

“So, by really looking at the patient as a whole, I can help them optimize themselves for healing, and we look at every possible advantage, every possible angle to help them achieve their desired outcome.”

If you’re in the middle group, your plan can include some combination of:

  • Appropriate rehab that is guided by your surgeon.
  • Regenerative medicine when it fits the diagnosis, such as platelet-rich plasma (PRP) or bone marrow aspirate (BMA).
  • Attention to your overall health, because your body is the thing that has to do the healing.

Not every option is right for every condition. Part of my job is telling you which ones make sense for your diagnosis, and which ones don’t.

How regenerative medicine, rehab and nutrition can work together for you

I put regenerative medicine, rehab and nutrition together as one plan for you.

“And that’s, you know, effective regenerative medicine, appropriate rehab that’s surgeon-guided with, you know, a strong line of communication between myself and the therapist.”

PRP is prepared from your own blood. BMA is collected from your own bone marrow. Whether either one is appropriate depends on your specific diagnosis and how severe it is. I’ll walk you through your options for your situation, and I won’t make blanket promises.

I stay in direct contact with my patients’ therapists so the rehab matches the diagnosis and the treatment.

Healing also takes raw materials. One of the first questions I ask myself about a patient is, “Are they getting enough protein to heal?”

The goal is to give you every reasonable advantage while you’re in that in-between stage, so you have something to do besides wait.

When surgery is the right next step for you

I’m an orthopedic surgeon, and I’m not against surgery. Some problems are better treated with an operation.

I tell patients plainly, “If someone truly needs surgery, I’m going to direct them that path.”

Surgery may become the right conversation when the exam and imaging show a problem that is better treated surgically.

And if surgery isn’t a good option for you right now, because of your health, your stage of life or your baseline function, something can still be done, and the plan has to fit you.

The point of seeing a surgeon who also offers regenerative care is that you hear about every option, surgery included.

Your next step

If you’ve been told you’re not bad enough for surgery, but you’re still in pain, you can start on a plan now, without waiting years for a follow-up appointment.

The next step is a candidacy call or an evaluation visit with me. We’ll look at your diagnosis, your imaging and your goals, and talk through which options make sense now, including when surgery should stay on the table. If you’ve already had an MRI, you can upload it before your visit.

To talk about your situation, call Vitality Orthopedics & Biologics at (860) 735-3744 or book online. The office is at 720 Hopmeadow Street, Suite 102, Simsbury, CT 06070. See the contact page for details.