Concierge Orthopedics | Expert Second Opinion

(860) 735-3744
Book Online
Refer a Friend

Do I Need Surgery? Why It Helps to Ask a Surgeon Who Also Offers Regenerative Care

Posted on: October 29th, 2026 by Connor Ziegler

Being told you need surgery can stop you in your tracks.

Maybe it came after a quick visit. Maybe the MRI report was full of words you didn’t recognize. Maybe a friend had a different treatment for something that sounds similar, and now you’re wondering whether surgery is really your only option.

Those are fair questions. The answer depends on your diagnosis, your health and your goals. But it also depends on something people don’t always think about: who is giving you the opinion.

Why it matters who gives the opinion

Every doctor brings their training and their tools to the conversation. If someone only offers surgery, surgery tends to be the answer. If someone only offers injections, you’ll likely hear about injections.

A single-path practice works that way, and nobody needs bad intent for it to happen. But if you’re truly on the fence, you want advice from someone who can weigh both sides.

“If someone is on the edge of surgery versus non-surgery, you have to see someone who can do both. I think you get the best opinion and the best expert opinion when you see someone who’s a full spectrum musculoskeletal specialist like myself.”

What “full-spectrum” care means for you

I’m a board-certified orthopedic surgeon. I also offer regenerative treatments such as platelet-rich plasma (PRP) and bone marrow aspirate (BMA). That combination shapes how I approach every decision.

I put it this way:

“You know, I think it really goes back to, you know, what my practice is structured on, which is, it’s full spectrum musculoskeletal care. So I’m not a non-operative provider, non-operative doctor that is solely biased towards non-operative treatment.”

“Musculoskeletal” just means your bones, joints, muscles, tendons and ligaments. In other words, I treat the whole range, with and without surgery, so I don’t have a reason to push you one way. My job is to find the path that fits you.

“So I really meet people where they are. You know, every situation, every joint, every patient circumstance is unique.”

When I recommend surgery

I don’t rule out surgery.

“If someone truly needs surgery, I’m going to direct them that path.”

When a non-surgical path is worth trying first

“So I don’t rule out surgery, but I certainly help people avoid it when I think it’s possible for them, and give them every tool they can to achieve that.”

When it fits your diagnosis, regenerative treatment such as PRP or BMA can be part of a non-surgical plan.

No plan comes with a guarantee that you’ll avoid surgery. What you get from me is a clear recommendation and the trade-offs behind it, so the decision is yours.

I bring the medical expertise, and you bring your goals and preferences.

If surgery is the answer, regenerative medicine can still be part of the plan

Surgery and regenerative care can work together. When an operation is the right call, I can still use regenerative tools to support your recovery.

“But I can also incorporate regenerative medicine to give them every advantage possible to make a stronger recovery.”

Questions to ask about any surgery recommendation

Whether you see me or someone else, these questions can help you understand a recommendation for surgery:

  • What exactly is causing my pain, and how sure are you?
  • What happens if I wait?
  • What non-surgical options are reasonable for my diagnosis, and why or why not?
  • If I have surgery, what does recovery look like?
  • Do you offer both surgical and non-surgical treatment for this problem?

If you’re on the edge, getting an opinion from someone who does both can give you more confidence in whichever path you choose.

Your next step

If you’ve been told you need surgery and want to be sure, or you’re wondering whether a non-surgical path could work for you, the next step is a candidacy call or an evaluation visit with me. We’ll go through your diagnosis, your imaging and your goals together, and I’ll give you a clear recommendation either way.

To talk about your situation, call Vitality Orthopedics & Biologics at (860) 735-3744 or book online. The office is at 720 Hopmeadow Street, Suite 102, Simsbury, CT 06070. See the contact page for details.