Concierge Orthopedics | Expert Second Opinion

(860) 735-3744
Book Online
Refer a Friend

Tennis Elbow That Won’t Go Away: Why Rest and Cortisone Aren’t Always Enough

Posted on: November 10th, 2026 by Connor Ziegler

“I’ve Rested It. Why Does My Elbow Still Hurt?”

It starts as a small annoyance.

Maybe you notice pain while playing tennis or pickleball.

Maybe it hurts when you’re working in the yard.

Or perhaps you don’t play racquet sports at all.

You simply notice that gripping a coffee mug, opening a jar, carrying groceries, or shaking someone’s hand suddenly hurts the outside of your elbow.

So you rest.

It feels a little better.

You return to your normal activities.

The pain comes back.

Eventually, you try:

  • Anti-inflammatory medication
  • An elbow brace
  • Physical therapy
  • Massage
  • Stretching
  • Cortisone

Maybe the cortisone works remarkably well—for a while.

Then several weeks or months later, the pain returns.

Now you’re asking:

“Why won’t this heal?”

This is where understanding tennis elbow becomes important.

Persistent tennis elbow isn’t always simply an inflammation problem.

And if the underlying tendon has lost its ability to tolerate the demands you’re placing on it, rest and repeated injections alone may not solve the problem.


A Patient Journey: The Weekend Tennis Player Who Can’t Shake Elbow Pain

Consider a 54-year-old active adult from Avon.

He plays tennis twice per week and occasionally plays pickleball with friends.

During the summer, he begins noticing soreness along the outside of his dominant elbow.

At first, he ignores it.

Then gripping the racquet becomes painful.

He takes two weeks off.

The elbow improves.

He returns to tennis.

Within several matches, the pain returns.

Eventually, everyday activities become uncomfortable.

He notices pain when:

  • Lifting a coffee mug
  • Carrying his briefcase
  • Opening a jar
  • Shaking hands
  • Picking up a grocery bag
  • Using a screwdriver
  • Gripping his tennis racquet

He tries an elbow strap.

He takes anti-inflammatory medication.

He stretches.

Eventually, he receives a cortisone injection.

For several weeks, he feels dramatically better.

He thinks:

“Finally. It’s fixed.”

Then the pain gradually returns.

Six months later, he’s still dealing with the same problem.

At this point, the question isn’t simply:

“How do we make the pain disappear temporarily?”

The better question is:

“Why has this tendon failed to recover?”


What Is Tennis Elbow?

Tennis elbow is the common name for lateral epicondylitis, although chronic cases are often better understood as a form of tendinopathy involving the tendons on the outside of the elbow.

These tendons connect muscles in the forearm to the outer portion of the elbow.

They help with movements involving:

  • Wrist extension
  • Gripping
  • Lifting
  • Racquet control
  • Repetitive hand and wrist activity

One tendon frequently involved is the extensor carpi radialis brevis, or ECRB.

When the tendon becomes overloaded or develops chronic tendon changes, patients may experience pain around the outside of the elbow.


You Don’t Have to Play Tennis to Get Tennis Elbow

The name is misleading.

Many patients with tennis elbow haven’t picked up a tennis racquet in years.

The condition can occur in people who:

  • Play tennis
  • Play pickleball
  • Golf
  • Lift weights
  • Garden
  • Perform construction work
  • Use tools
  • Work with their hands
  • Perform repetitive computer or occupational tasks
  • Frequently lift or carry objects

What these activities may have in common is repeated demand on the muscles and tendons that control the wrist and hand.


Why Does Tennis Elbow Become Chronic?

Early tendon pain may involve a reactive response to increased load.

But when symptoms persist for months, the problem can become more complicated.

Chronic tendinopathy may involve changes in:

  • Tendon structure
  • Collagen organization
  • Tendon cells
  • Blood vessel growth
  • Pain signaling
  • The tendon’s ability to tolerate load

This is one reason the term tendinopathy is often more useful than simply thinking of the condition as “inflammation.”

If the problem were purely inflammation, reducing inflammation should reliably solve it.

For many patients with chronic tennis elbow, it doesn’t.


Why Rest Often Helps—But Doesn’t Always Fix the Problem

Rest makes intuitive sense.

If an activity hurts, stop doing it.

And temporarily reducing irritating activity can absolutely be useful.

The problem occurs when rest becomes the entire treatment plan.

Suppose your tendon can currently tolerate a certain amount of force.

Tennis, pickleball, weight training, or work repeatedly exceeds that capacity.

You stop the activity for four weeks.

The pain settles.

But during those four weeks, you haven’t necessarily improved the tendon or surrounding muscle’s ability to tolerate load.

Then you return immediately to the same activity at the same intensity.

The demand once again exceeds capacity.

The pain returns.

This creates a frustrating cycle:

Activity → pain → rest → improvement → return to activity → pain again.

Patients may repeat this for months or even years.


Rest and Rehabilitation Are Not the Same Thing

This distinction is critical.

Rest reduces demand.

Rehabilitation attempts to increase capacity.

For many tendon problems, the long-term goal is not simply making the tendon experience less stress.

It is helping the entire muscle-tendon system become capable of tolerating appropriate stress again.

That often requires progressive exercise.


The Load vs. Capacity Problem

A useful way to understand tennis elbow is:

Demand > Tendon Capacity = Symptoms

Imagine a recreational tennis player who hasn’t played all winter.

Spring arrives.

He begins playing four days per week.

His cardiovascular fitness may be fine.

His tennis skills may return quickly.

But his forearm tendons may not be prepared for the sudden increase in repetitive gripping and racquet forces.

Symptoms develop.

The goal shouldn’t necessarily be to stop tennis forever.

The goal is to gradually restore enough capacity to tolerate tennis again.


Why Cortisone Can Feel So Effective

Corticosteroid injections can provide significant short-term pain relief for some patients.

That’s why patients often love them initially.

The elbow may have hurt for months.

Then an injection dramatically reduces the symptoms.

It feels like the problem has finally been solved.

But pain relief and tendon recovery aren’t necessarily the same thing.

If the patient feels better and immediately returns to the same workload without addressing strength, mechanics, and tendon capacity, the underlying problem may remain.


The Cortisone Question: Short-Term Relief vs. Long-Term Strategy

Cortisone has an important role in orthopedic medicine.

But it isn’t automatically the best solution for every chronic tendon problem.

Research examining lateral elbow tendinopathy has raised concerns about relying on corticosteroid injections as a long-term strategy.

Some studies have demonstrated good short-term symptom relief but less favorable recurrence or longer-term outcomes compared with approaches that don’t rely on corticosteroid injection.

That doesn’t mean cortisone is always “bad.”

It means the treatment should match the condition and the goal.

For a chronic tendon problem, the important question becomes:

Are we temporarily suppressing pain, or are we developing a strategy to restore function?


Why Repeated Cortisone Deserves Careful Consideration

Patients sometimes enter a cycle:

Pain → cortisone → relief → pain returns → another injection.

If symptoms repeatedly return, simply repeating the same intervention may not address why the tendon continues to hurt.

Repeated corticosteroid exposure around tendons also deserves careful consideration because corticosteroids can affect tendon tissue.

This is particularly important when the goal is long-term tendon health.

Rather than automatically repeating another injection, persistent symptoms may warrant a reassessment of:

  • The diagnosis
  • Tendon condition
  • Strength
  • Activity demands
  • Rehabilitation program
  • Other treatment options

Could the Diagnosis Be Wrong?

Not every case of pain on the outside of the elbow is tennis elbow.

Other conditions can sometimes produce similar symptoms.

These may include:

  • Radial tunnel syndrome
  • Nerve irritation
  • Elbow arthritis
  • Ligament problems
  • Referred pain from the neck
  • Other tendon or joint disorders

This becomes especially important when a patient says:

“I’ve been treating tennis elbow for a year and nothing has worked.”

Before escalating treatment, it’s worth confirming that tennis elbow is actually the correct diagnosis.


What Does an Orthopedic Examination Look For?

The diagnosis often begins with the history and physical examination.

An orthopedic evaluation may assess:

  • Exact location of pain
  • Tenderness
  • Grip strength
  • Wrist strength
  • Pain with resisted wrist extension
  • Elbow motion
  • Stability
  • Nerve symptoms
  • Neck symptoms
  • Activities that reproduce the pain

The physician is trying to determine not only whether the tendon hurts, but whether another condition could be contributing.


Do You Need an MRI for Tennis Elbow?

Not every patient with new elbow pain needs an MRI.

Many cases can initially be diagnosed clinically.

But imaging may become useful when:

  • Symptoms have persisted
  • Treatment has failed
  • There is significant weakness
  • The diagnosis is uncertain
  • A tendon tear is suspected
  • A procedure is being considered
  • Another condition needs to be ruled out

MRI can help evaluate the common extensor tendon and surrounding structures.

For chronic elbow pain that has not improved despite appropriate treatment, advanced imaging can provide useful information when determining what to do next.


Why Physical Therapy Can Help

Good tendon rehabilitation is more than stretching the forearm.

A comprehensive program may address:

  • Wrist extensor strength
  • Grip strength
  • Forearm strength
  • Shoulder strength
  • Scapular mechanics
  • Mobility
  • Activity modification
  • Progressive loading

Why look at the shoulder for an elbow problem?

Because the upper extremity functions as a chain.

In tennis and pickleball, force is transferred from the:

Legs → trunk → shoulder → elbow → wrist → racquet.

If one part of that system isn’t functioning well, another area may have to absorb more demand.


Progressive Tendon Loading

One of the central concepts in modern tendinopathy rehabilitation is progressive loading.

The exact program should be individualized.

Depending on the patient and stage of recovery, exercises may include:

  • Isometric exercises
  • Controlled wrist extension
  • Eccentric strengthening
  • Concentric strengthening
  • Grip exercises
  • Progressive resistance training
  • Sport-specific loading

The objective is not simply:

“Stretch it until it stops hurting.”

The objective is to gradually build the tendon’s ability to tolerate the demands required for everyday life, work, and sport.


Should Tendon Exercises Hurt?

Patients often assume that any pain during rehabilitation means they are causing damage.

That isn’t always true.

With some tendon rehabilitation programs, a small amount of discomfort may be acceptable.

But severe or progressively worsening pain may indicate that the exercise load is too high.

This is why rehabilitation should be adjusted based on:

  • Symptoms during exercise
  • Symptoms afterward
  • Next-day response
  • Strength
  • Functional progress

The right amount of loading can be therapeutic.

Too little may not create adaptation.

Too much may repeatedly aggravate the tendon.


What About an Elbow Brace?

Counterforce straps and wrist braces can sometimes reduce symptoms during activity.

They may be useful tools.

But a brace doesn’t necessarily restore tendon capacity.

Think of bracing as potentially helping manage symptoms while the underlying problem is addressed.

If you need the brace every day for two years just to tolerate normal activity, it’s reasonable to ask whether a more comprehensive treatment plan is needed.


What About Anti-Inflammatory Medication?

Anti-inflammatory medications may help reduce pain in some patients.

But again, chronic tennis elbow isn’t always simply an inflammatory problem.

Medication may help manage symptoms without correcting:

  • Tendon weakness
  • Poor load tolerance
  • Inadequate rehabilitation
  • Repetitive overload
  • Technique problems

Medication may be one component of treatment—not necessarily the entire solution.


What About Shockwave Therapy?

Extracorporeal shockwave therapy has also been studied for chronic tendinopathies, including lateral elbow tendinopathy.

The treatment delivers mechanical energy to the affected area.

Some patients may benefit, although research results vary depending on:

  • Condition
  • Treatment protocol
  • Duration of symptoms
  • Device
  • Patient selection

 


Where Does PRP Fit for Chronic Tennis Elbow?

Platelet-rich plasma—or PRP—is one treatment that may be considered for selected patients with chronic tennis elbow.

PRP is prepared from the patient’s own blood.

A blood sample is processed to concentrate platelets.

Platelets contain signaling proteins and growth factors involved in the body’s normal healing response.

The PRP is then injected into the targeted area of the abnormal tendon.


Why Is PRP Different From Cortisone?

The treatment goals are different.

Cortisone is generally used for its anti-inflammatory and pain-relieving effects.

PRP is intended to influence the biological environment surrounding the tendon.

That doesn’t mean PRP instantly “heals” the tendon.

And it doesn’t mean PRP works for every patient.

But for selected chronic tendon conditions, PRP may be considered when symptoms continue despite appropriate conservative treatment.


What Does the Research Say About PRP for Tennis Elbow?

Research comparing PRP with corticosteroid injections has produced an important general pattern.

Corticosteroid injections may provide stronger short-term symptom relief in some patients.

PRP may take longer to produce improvement, but some studies and reviews have reported more favorable outcomes at later follow-up periods.

However, the literature isn’t perfectly consistent.

PRP preparations differ.

Injection techniques differ.

Rehabilitation protocols differ.

And not every study shows the same magnitude of benefit.

That’s why PRP shouldn’t be presented as:

“The cure for tennis elbow.”

A more accurate message is:

PRP may be a reasonable treatment option for selected patients with chronic lateral elbow tendinopathy who have not improved with appropriate rehabilitation and other conservative treatment.


PRP Is Not an Instant Pain Injection

This is an important expectation to establish.

Patients accustomed to cortisone may expect:

Injection today → pain gone tomorrow.

PRP is different.

Patients may experience temporary soreness after the procedure.

Improvement, when it occurs, generally develops gradually.

The recovery process may take:

  • Weeks
  • Sometimes several months

During that period, rehabilitation and progressive loading remain important.

 


What Happens After PRP for Tennis Elbow?

Protocols vary based on the patient and physician.

A recovery plan may include:

  • Temporary reduction in strenuous gripping
  • Gradual return to normal movement
  • Progressive tendon loading
  • Forearm strengthening
  • Grip strengthening
  • Shoulder and scapular strengthening
  • Gradual return to tennis, pickleball, golf, or work

The objective is to combine the biological treatment with an appropriate mechanical rehabilitation plan.


Can You Play Tennis or Pickleball After PRP?

Eventually, that is often the goal.

But returning too quickly may overload a tendon that is still recovering.

A better return-to-sport plan gradually restores:

  1. Comfortable everyday activity
  2. Grip strength
  3. Forearm strength
  4. Controlled racquet work
  5. Short practice sessions
  6. Progressive playing time
  7. Full competition

Return should be based on function and recovery—not simply a date on the calendar.


Technique and Equipment Matter Too

For racquet-sport athletes, rehabilitation shouldn’t stop at the elbow.

Factors worth considering may include:

  • Grip size
  • Racquet weight
  • String tension
  • Stroke mechanics
  • Frequency of play
  • Training volume
  • Warm-up
  • Recovery between sessions

A recreational player who suddenly goes from one match per week to four may have a workload problem rather than simply an “elbow problem.”

Similarly, poor mechanics may repeatedly expose the tendon to unnecessary stress.


Tennis Elbow in Pickleball Players

Pickleball has introduced many active adults to racquet sports.

That’s a good thing.

But a rapid increase in playing frequency can expose the elbow to repetitive gripping and striking loads it hasn’t previously experienced.

A new player may go from virtually no racquet activity to playing:

  • Three days per week
  • Four days per week
  • Sometimes every day

The enthusiasm is high.

The tendon capacity may not be.

This is another example of why gradual progression matters.


Why Chronic Tendon Problems Require Patience

Tendons don’t always recover as quickly as patients would like.

That’s frustrating.

A patient may say:

“It’s been six weeks. Why isn’t it healed?”

But chronic tendon problems may have developed over many months or years.

Restoring tendon capacity can take time.

Progress may involve:

  • Less pain with gripping
  • Improved strength
  • Better tolerance for exercise
  • Longer periods of activity
  • Faster recovery after activity

Success shouldn’t always be measured only by whether pain is completely absent today.

The direction of progress matters.


When Is Surgery Considered?

Most cases of tennis elbow are treated without surgery.

However, surgery may be considered for selected patients with persistent symptoms that have failed an appropriate course of non-surgical treatment.

Surgical options generally address the abnormal portion of the tendon and surrounding tissue.

But surgery isn’t usually the first step.

Before considering it, the physician may review:

  • Duration of symptoms
  • Imaging
  • Diagnosis
  • Rehabilitation history
  • Previous injections
  • Strength
  • Functional limitations
  • Patient goals

The goal isn’t to avoid surgery at all costs.

It is to determine whether surgery is actually necessary.


When Should You See an Orthopedic Specialist for Tennis Elbow?

Consider an evaluation if:

  • Elbow pain has persisted for several weeks or months
  • Symptoms repeatedly return after rest
  • Grip strength has declined
  • Everyday activities hurt
  • You have already tried physical therapy without improvement
  • Cortisone helped only temporarily
  • You’ve had multiple injections
  • You cannot return to tennis, pickleball, golf, or exercise
  • The diagnosis is uncertain
  • Pain is getting worse instead of better

Persistent symptoms don’t automatically mean you need an injection or surgery.

They mean it may be time to determine why the problem isn’t improving.


Chronic Tennis Elbow Treatment in Simsbury and the Farmington Valley

At Vitality Orthopedics & Biologics in Simsbury, Connecticut, we evaluate active adults with persistent tendon and joint problems who want to understand why their symptoms continue and what treatment options are available.

We serve patients throughout:

  • Simsbury
  • Avon
  • Farmington
  • Canton
  • Granby
  • West Hartford
  • The greater Farmington Valley

Patients with chronic elbow pain often come to us after saying:

  • “I’ve rested it and it keeps coming back.”
  • “Physical therapy didn’t completely solve it.”
  • “The cortisone worked, but only temporarily.”
  • “I can’t play tennis anymore.”
  • “Pickleball keeps aggravating it.”
  • “I don’t want another cortisone injection.”
  • “I want to know whether PRP is an option.”

The first step isn’t automatically PRP.

The first step is determining why the elbow still hurts.


The Bottom Line: Stop Treating Only the Pain

When tennis elbow lasts for months, the problem may no longer be as simple as:

“My elbow is inflamed.”

The tendon may have lost its ability to tolerate the demands you’re placing on it.

That’s why the cycle of:

Rest → feel better → return to activity → pain returns

can continue indefinitely.

And it’s why repeated temporary pain relief doesn’t necessarily mean the underlying problem has been corrected.

For chronic tennis elbow, successful treatment may require a broader strategy:

Confirm the diagnosis.

Understand the tendon.

Modify the irritating load.

Rebuild strength.

Progressively reload the tendon.

Consider additional treatments when appropriate.

For selected patients, PRP may become part of that strategy.

For others, better rehabilitation may be the missing piece.

And occasionally, a different diagnosis or surgical problem may be discovered.

The important step is understanding why the elbow isn’t getting better.

Tennis Elbow Still Bothering You?

If you’ve already tried rest, bracing, medication, physical therapy, or cortisone and your elbow pain continues to interfere with tennis, pickleball, golf, work, or everyday activities, it may be time for a more comprehensive evaluation.

Schedule a Comprehensive Orthopedic Consultation

Vitality Orthopedics & Biologics
720 Hopmeadow Street, Suite 102
Simsbury, CT

📞 (860) 735-3744
🌐 vitalityorthopedics.com

Serving Simsbury, Avon, Farmington, Canton, Granby, West Hartford, and the greater Farmington Valley.